Everton is currently embroiled in a debate over whether to sell Dominic Calvert-Lewin before the transfer window closes, according to the Liverpool Echo.
Chris Beesley reports that there are mixed feelings within Goodison Park’s corridors of power. Some officials are eager to secure a transfer fee for the striker, who has just 12 months left on his contract. However, others argue that selling him for below market value this summer would leave Sean Dyche’s squad dangerously short on attacking options, and it might be more prudent to let him depart on a free transfer next year.
Everton has offered the 27-year-old an extension, but the uncertainty surrounding the club’s ownership—especially after Dan Friedkin’s failed takeover—has likely diminished the chances of Calvert-Lewin signing a new deal, according to The Times.
Ideally, the Toffees hope Calvert-Lewin will agree to an extension with a clause allowing a future sale for a full fee if a suitable offer arises. However, Calvert-Lewin might prefer a clearer future, even if it means leaving on a free transfer next summer.
The second-best scenario would involve selling him now for a reduced fee and securing a suitable replacement. Yet, long-term suitors Newcastle withdrew from talks during their pursuit of Yakuba Minteh in June, leaving no current buyers for Calvert-Lewin, according to Ian Croll.
Everton’s attempts to sign replacements have also been thwarted. Tammy Abraham turned them down (Sky Sports Italia, 30 July), and doubts remain about Chelsea’s Armando Broja, although a bid has reportedly been made (El Chiringuito TV, 30 July).
Beto showed promise last season, and Youssef Chermiti impressed during preseason, suggesting he might be ready for a more prominent role. However, losing Calvert-Lewin without a solid replacement would be risky, especially with Neal Maupay available for transfer (TEAMtalk, 2 August).
Financial concerns are looming again for Everton. Kieran Maguire warned on 31 July that without an imminent takeover, the club might need to sell one of its prized assets before the window closes. Jarrad Branthwaite, being highly valuable and sought after, is a likely candidate. However, any offer for Calvert-Lewin might also have to be considered.
Ultimately, if Calvert-Lewin’s goals could be the difference between Premier League survival and relegation, his value on the pitch might far exceed any cut-price transfer fee, despite some doubts raised by his preseason performances.
