DUNCAN FERGUSON DISMANTLES JAMIE CARRAGHER AS UGLY FEUD TURNS PERSONAL DEMANDING HE MUST DO ONE THING FOR THE ENTIRE EVERTON FANS

The tension between Duncan Ferguson and Jamie Carragher has escalated into a full-blown personal feud following their recent viral confrontation on Sky Sports. What began as a heated tactical debate over Everton’s identity has reportedly turned “ugly,” with Ferguson dismantling Carragher’s criticisms and taking the fight directly to the Liverpool icon. Far from accepting Carragher’s subsequent social media explanation, “Big Dunc” has reportedly doubled down, making a singular, non-negotiable demand to settle the score: Jamie Carragher must issue a formal, public apology live on Sky Sports to the entire Everton fanbase.
​According to sources close to the situation, Ferguson feels that Carragher’s remarks—which he labeled “stupid” during the broadcast—crossed a line from objective analysis into personal and club-wide disrespect. Ferguson has reportedly told associates that a lengthy statement on X or a discussion on a podcast is a “coward’s way out” and fails to address the damage done to the pride of the Blue half of Merseyside. For Ferguson, the only acceptable resolution is for Carragher to look into the camera during a live broadcast and admit that his comments lacked a fundamental understanding of what Everton stands for.
​The drama has sent shockwaves through the sports media world, with many wondering if the duo can ever share a studio again. While Carragher is known for standing his ground, the immense pressure from the Everton faithful, unified behind their legendary striker, has made this more than just a punditry spat. Ferguson’s “demand” is being viewed by supporters as a necessary defense of the club’s heritage against what they perceive as biased “Big Six” commentary.
​As the standoff continues, all eyes are on the next Sky Sports Monday Night Football billing. If Carragher refuses to offer the public apology Ferguson is demanding, the atmosphere in the studio is expected to be ice-cold. One thing is certain: in this battle of Merseyside giants, Duncan Ferguson has made it clear that he isn’t just fighting for himself—he’s fighting for every fan who felt belittled by the comments, and he won’t rest until the respect he feels the club is owed is delivered on the same platform where it was taken away.