Alan Shearer Tears Into Newcastle’s Three Players After Humiliating Derby Defeat

Alan Shearer Tears Into Newcastle’s Three Players After Humiliating Derby Defeat

In a scathing post-match verdict that has sent shockwaves through Tyneside, Newcastle United legend Alan Shearer didn’t hold back after his former club’s abject 1-0 loss to rivals Sunderland in the fiercely contested Tyne-Wear derby on December 14, 2025.

geordiebootboys.com The defeat at the Stadium of Light, sealed by a freak own goal from Newcastle defender Nick Woltemade just a minute into the second half, extended the Magpies’ winless run against the Black Cats to a dismal 10 Premier League games—a record Shearer branded “embarrassing.”

geordiebootboys.comShearer, the Premier League’s all-time leading scorer and a lifelong Newcastle icon, reserved his harshest words for the forward line, pinpointing their woeful display as the primary culprit for the downfall. Posting on X (formerly Twitter), the 55-year-old pundit unleashed: “Offered nothing up front at all. Awful. Miles off it for a derby game. #SUNNEW.”

newcastleworld.com His 14-word takedown cut deep, eviscerating the trio of Anthony Gordon, Anthony Elanga, and Nick Woltemade—who, ironically, netted the decisive own goal off a Nordi Mukiele cross—for their collective impotence.

sportsmole.co.ukNewcastle dominated possession post-interval but mustered just two shots on target, both tame efforts from midfielder Bruno Guimarães that Sunderland keeper Remi Roefs swatted away with ease.

newcastleworld.com Gordon, the £40m summer signing expected to ignite the attack, carried zero threat, vanishing in the cauldron of derby pressure. Elanga, deployed on the right, was equally dire—guilty of wayward crosses and a lack of incision that left fans fuming. Even Woltemade, thrust forward in desperation, flailed without menace. “Disgraceful,” one supporter tweeted, echoing Shearer’s fury. “Our stars hid when it mattered most.”

geordiebootboys.comManager Eddie Howe defended his charges’ effort but conceded the “quality was missing,” admitting the intensity spiked too late after substitutions.

newcastleworld.com For Shearer, though, excuses won’t cut it in a fixture that transcends points. This loss, the first league derby reverse since 2016, piles pressure on Howe’s rebuild amid mounting injury woes—Alexander Isak’s absence up top was keenly felt.As Newcastle lick their wounds ahead of the March 21, 2026 return clash at St James’ Park, Shearer’s words sting like a Geordie gale: the forwards’ failure wasn’t just poor—it was derby-day betrayal. Will Gordon and Elanga step up, or will the ghosts of this flop haunt another season? For now, the Toon Army’s heroes have been unmasked as zeroes.(Word count: 312)