Nottingham Forest Fans Call for Star Player Sale After Fulham Defeat

Nottingham Forest Fans Call for Star Player Sale After Fulham Defeat

Nottingham Forest supporters are growing increasingly frustrated with summer signing James McAtee following the team’s 1-0 Premier League defeat to Fulham on December 22, 2025. The 23-year-old midfielder, who joined from Manchester City in a deal worth up to £30 million, came on as a substitute in the 73rd minute but failed to influence the game, as Forest chased an equalizer against Raúl Jiménez’s first-half penalty.

McAtee’s brief cameo drew sharp criticism, with fans labeling his performance ineffective and symptomatic of his struggles since arriving at the City Ground. On social media platforms like X (formerly Twitter), Reds supporters vented their anger, calling him a “waste of money” and “not good enough” for the Premier League level. Posts highlighted his lack of impact, with one fan stating he “looks like a soft junior player,” while others demanded he be sold or loaned out in January to recoup funds.The England U21 international, reportedly earning around £40,000 per week, has made limited appearances this season, often as a substitute or in Europa League fixtures. His perceived high wage—potentially closer to figures fans exaggerate as £60k—has fueled accusations of poor value, especially amid Forest’s relegation battle in 17th place.

Despite reports that manager Sean Dyche has no intention of letting McAtee leave in January, viewing him as a long-term investment with potential in Europe, fan pressure is mounting. Many argue the club should prioritize experienced reinforcements over retaining underperforming fringe players like McAtee, whose integration has been hampered by managerial changes and competition from Morgan Gibbs-White.

As the January window approaches, McAtee’s future remains a hot topic among the Trent End faithful, who fear his continued presence could hinder Forest’s survival push. Whether the club heeds the calls remains to be seen, but the backlash underscores the high expectations—and impatience—surrounding big-money signings.