Premier League release statement explaining why Anthony Gordon’s goal was disallowed vs Crystal Palace in controversial circumstances

Premier League Releases Statement Explaining Anthony Gordon’s Disallowed Goal Against Crystal Palace

Following Newcastle United’s 2-0 win over Crystal Palace on January 4, 2026, at St. James’ Park, the Premier League has responded to widespread fan frustration over Anthony Gordon’s disallowed goal in the 19th minute. The incident, which many supporters branded a “clear error” by VAR, has once again thrust the controversial technology into the spotlight.

The match saw Newcastle control large periods but struggle to convert chances until Bruno Guimarães (71′) and Malick Thiaw (78′) struck late to secure the three points. In the first half, Gordon seemed to have opened the scoring when Yoane Wissa raced in behind the defence and squared the ball for the winger to tap home. The goal was initially given, only for a prolonged VAR check to rule it out for offside against Wissa in the build-up.

Social media reaction was swift and fierce, with thousands of posts, screenshots, and slow-motion replays circulating online. Newcastle fans in particular argued the call was marginal, with many claiming Wissa was level or even onside. Manager Eddie Howe voiced his disappointment after the game, saying, “It looked very tight on the replays we saw. Those decisions can swing momentum, and we need more clarity around how they’re made.”On January 5, the Premier League, working alongside Professional Game Match Officials Limited (PGMOL), published an official explanation. The statement confirmed the use of semi-automated offside technology (SAOT), which applies a 5cm tolerance threshold to account for minor camera and positioning inaccuracies. According to the league, Wissa was measured as offside by 7cm—exceeding the tolerance limit—and the decision was therefore upheld under current IFAB laws.

The release read: “The system is designed to deliver the highest possible accuracy while preserving the flow and spirit of the game. In this case, the offside line was definitively established, and the call aligns with the established protocols. We recognise the passion this generates among supporters and remain committed to continuous improvement of VAR processes.”

The explanation has divided opinion. Some welcomed the transparency, while others pointed to perceived inconsistencies in similar tight calls across the season. PGMOL chief Howard Webb has indicated that full VAR audio from the incident will be made available in due course to provide further context.

The episode highlights the ongoing challenge of balancing technological precision with fan expectations in the Premier League. As Newcastle looks ahead to their next fixtures, the debate over Gordon’s “ghost goal” is likely to continue for some time.