Rabiu AminuPremier League Releases VAR Audio from Michael Keane’s Controversial Red Card in Everton vs Wolves ClashIn a move aimed at increasing transparency in officiating, the Premier League has released the VAR audio from the heated Everton vs Wolves match on January 7, 2026, at Goodison Park. The footage centers on the 83rd-minute incident where Everton defender Michael Keane was shown a straight red card for pulling the hair of Wolves striker Tolu Arokodare. The game, which ended in a 1-1 draw, saw Everton reduced to nine men after Jack Grealish was also dismissed, sparking widespread debate over refereeing decisions.
The released audio, made public via the PGMOL’s official channels on January 8, provides a behind-the-scenes look at the VAR review process. On-field referee Anthony Taylor initially waved play on after Keane and Arokodare clashed during an aerial duel. However, VAR official Chris Kavanagh intervened, prompting a monitor check.
In the audio, Kavanagh is heard saying: “Anthony, I recommend an on-field review for possible violent conduct. The defender has grabbed the attacker’s hair with force—it’s not part of a natural challenge.” Taylor responds: “Okay, showing me the angle.” After reviewing multiple replays, Taylor confirms: “Yeah, that’s clear. It’s unnatural and violent. Red card for violent conduct.” The exchange lasts just over a minute, highlighting the quick but decisive nature of the call.
Everton manager David Moyes, already vocal post-match, blasted the decision as “ridiculous” in his press conference. “Pulling hair? In the heat of a battle? We’ve seen worse go unpunished,” Moyes said. “Releasing the audio is a step forward, but it doesn’t change the fact that it cost us the game.” Keane, who had earlier scored Everton’s opener with a powerful header, expressed frustration on social media: “Gutted about the red. Never meant to hurt anyone—just competing for the ball.”
Wolves boss Gary O’Neil defended the call, noting Arokodare’s visible discomfort. “Tolu felt it, and the audio shows why it was red. VAR got it right this time.” Arokodare, the 25-year-old Nigerian forward who equalized for Wolves, downplayed the incident: “It’s football—things happen. No hard feelings.”
The release comes amid growing calls for more VAR openness following a season plagued by controversies. PGMOL chief Howard Webb stated: “By sharing this, we aim to educate fans and build trust in the system.” Critics, however, argue it exposes inconsistencies, with some pointing to similar unpunished incidents in past games.
This incident has reignited discussions on what constitutes “violent conduct.” With Everton now facing a suspension for Keane, the Toffees’ relegation battle intensifies. As the Premier League evolves its tech, such releases could become standard, potentially reducing post-match fury but raising questions about real-time access.
Fans on social media are divided, with #VARAudio trending. Some praise the transparency, while others mock the “hair-pulling red” as overly soft. As the league pushes for clarity, this audio drop marks a pivotal moment in English football’s ongoing VAR saga.
Qudus Salihu
Rabiu Aminu
Mustapha Sheidu
