Rabiu AminuMoyes’ Bold Call: Branthwaite Benched for Bournemouth Clash Sparks Everton Fan FuryIn a decision that has ignited a firestorm among Everton supporters, manager David Moyes has opted to leave star defender Jarrad Branthwaite out of the starting lineup for tonight’s Premier League clash against AFC Bournemouth at Hill Dickinson Stadium. The young English center-back, who has been a cornerstone of the Toffees’ defense this season, finds himself on the bench as Moyes prioritizes managing his workload following a recent injury layoff. With kick-off looming at 7:30 PM GMT, the move has left fans seething, questioning the Scot’s tactics at a crucial juncture in Everton’s push for European spots.
Branthwaite, 23, has been hailed as one of Everton’s brightest talents, drawing comparisons to top Premier League defenders with his composure, aerial prowess, and ability to read the game. His performances have not only solidified the backline but also attracted interest from bigger clubs. However, after being eased back into action with a substitute appearance in the recent draw at Fulham, Moyes cited the need to “cage his minutes” in a pre-match press conference. “We’re nursing one or two players back to full fitness,” Moyes explained. “Jarrad’s important, but we can’t risk him burning out.” Instead, Ukrainian international Vitaliy Mykolenko is set to partner Michael Keane in central defense, a pairing that has drawn immediate backlash for its perceived lack of dynamism.
Social media erupted within minutes of the team news leaking. On X (formerly Twitter), Everton fans voiced their outrage, with one user posting, “Moyes out! Clueless team selection again—dropping Branthwaite for Mykolenko? We’re destroying our best players’ confidence!” Another fumed, “How do you bench your star defender against a tricky Bournemouth side? This is why we’re stuck in mid-table mediocrity.” The sentiment echoes broader frustrations with Moyes’ conservative approach, reminiscent of criticisms during his West Ham tenure. Supporters argue that with Everton sitting ninth in the table—twice as far from relegation as from the top four—this is no time for caution. A raucous atmosphere was anticipated to propel the team toward a vital win, but now many fear it could turn hostile if results don’t go their way.Bournemouth, under Andoni Iraola, arrive on a five-game unbeaten streak, posing a real threat with their counter-attacking pace. Everton will rely on the likes of Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall and Charly Alcaraz in midfield, while up front, Beto aims to build on his late equalizer against Brighton. Jack Grealish remains sidelined with a foot injury, adding to the selection headaches.
Moyes, no stranger to pressure, defended his choices: “I like my players fighting for spots—it breeds competition.” But as chants of “Moyes Out” linger from past seasons, this call could test fan patience further. A victory might quell the storm; a loss could amplify it. With Everton eyeing Europe, tonight’s result—and Branthwaite’s potential second-half impact—could define the mood at Goodison’s successor stadium.
Mustapha Sheidu
Rabiu Aminu
Qudus Salihu