PGMOL release full VAR transcript for Dujan Sterling controversial handball in draw vs Celtic

The Scottish FA (SFA) has released the full VAR transcript from the controversial Dujon Sterling handball incident in the recent Old Firm derby, where referee John Beaton awarded Celtic a late penalty that secured a 2-2 draw at Ibrox.

The decision, made in the 87th minute, came after Daizen Maeda’s header struck Sterling’s outstretched left arm inside the penalty area. Beaton initially played on but reviewed the incident at the pitchside monitor following VAR intervention, pointing to the spot. Reo Hatate converted after Jack Butland saved the initial kick and the rebound, bundling home on the third attempt to deny Rangers a vital win.

The release follows intense post-match debate, with Rangers boss Danny Rohl labeling the penalty “lucky” and questioning the interpretation of Sterling’s arm position as unnatural. Celtic supporters and pundits defended the call as correct under current handball laws, emphasizing the arm making the body bigger and blocking a goalbound effort.

SFA head of refereeing operations Crawford Allan commented: “In line with our commitment to greater transparency in high-profile matches, we’ve made the VAR audio and transcript available promptly. This helps all stakeholders understand the decision-making process.

“### Full VAR Transcript (Released by SFA):**VAR (Steven McLean):** “Checking potential handball in the box, Rangers number 21 [Sterling]. Ball from cross, header by Maeda, strikes arm.”**AVAR (Kevin Clancy):** “Arm is extended, away from body, changes direction of the ball. On target before contact.”**VAR:** “Yes, clear contact. Arm position unnatural, increases body size, prevents goalscoring opportunity. Recommend on-field review for referee.”**Referee (John Beaton):** “Received, heading to monitor.”

*[Short pause for review]***Referee (John Beaton):** “Confirmed. Handball – arm makes body unnaturally bigger, deliberate block on goalbound header. Penalty to Celtic. No red card, as it’s not DOGSO outside context, accidental but punishable under law.

“**VAR:** “Decision upheld. Reset for penalty kick.”The transcript, captured in under 90 seconds, shows a standard application of IFAB handball guidelines, focusing on arm position and outcome rather than intent alone. Rangers have acknowledged the release but reiterated their view that the arm was in a natural running position, potentially setting a precedent for similar incidents.

The draw keeps Hearts clear at the top of the Scottish Premiership, while both Old Firm sides remain in pursuit. As scrutiny on officiating continues, this fast-tracked disclosure—mirroring past releases like the Alistair Johnston and Auston Trusty cases—aims to build trust amid ongoing calls for even more openness in VAR processes.